Are electric bikes cheating?

Yes. Yes, they are. And No. No, they're not

The UK is a funny old place sometimes. Head out on an electric city bike in any town, or rock up at a trail centre with an electric mountain bike, and you're sure to get some attention: lot of people are curious about electric bikes. But sooner or later (sooner, in my experience) you'll get asked: aren't you cheating? Sometimes even car drivers will ask you that, which is pretty ironic as they sit in an armchair surrounded by two tons of metal and a combustion engine. Anyway, there’s more than one answer to this old chestnut...

Yes, of course it’s cheating

Having a big old motor give you a helping hand is clearly cheating. And, as pretty much anyone who’s ever tried it will will tell you, this is A Good Thing.

Moustache Samedi Open Xroad 5 - motor.jpg
Yes: this will make your riding easier

You can ride for longer, or for the same distance with minimal effort. A motor flattens out the topography, making hilly rides in normal clothes a reality. You can go off exploring up that hill or down that path without worrying about it being a waste of your limited energy. You can sail up the long fire road climb to where the fun starts. And then when you reach at the bottom you can sail up it again. It’s very liberating. It changes the nature of climbing completely, especially on a mountain bike. What used to be the slog to get to the good bit now becomes a good bit in itself. You get to enjoy the whole of the ride.

It’s fun. You’re out in the fresh air. You don’t have to tax your vehicle. You don’t need special training, or much equipment, or expensive insurance. It doesn’t cost anything to park. It costs basically nothing to refuel. It’s fun. Oh, I said that. What’s not to like? If you’re out cycling solely for fitness then you can work as hard on an e-bike as you can on a standard bike, if you want to, and that extra input from the motor might be the difference between keeping up with your fitter ride buddies, or getting dropped off the back. If getting about easily is your main concern, you can do the same ride for less effort. But even then, riding an e-bike is giving you much more of a workout than sitting in your car.

No, of course it’s not cheating

This notion that an e-bike is some kind of nefarious and unfair advantage is mostly a reflection of the UK's relationship with the bike as a whole. Back in the first half of the latter century, everyone cycled everywhere. They did it because it was an easy and cheap way to get around. Cars were expensive and relatively uncommon. But the advent of mass motoring, and the lack of provision for cycle travel in transport planning for many decades, saw everyday cycling sidelined. Modal share for bikes dropped to low-single-digit percentages almost everywhere as cars took over our towns and cities.

Castle Combe racing
A motor would be frowned upon here. But it wouldn't be much use anyway if it cuts out at 25km/h... (photo © Rich Lewton)

I'm exactly the kind of sport cyclist I've described above. I hold a British Cycling license and I race in the 3rd cats, one rung up from the bottom. I don't ride an e-bike for those races, it's not allowed. I do ride e-bikes though, all the time. Some days I'll put on my lycra and smash out an hour of hard graft before work. Other days I'll hop on the e-bike and roll down the hill, safe in the knowledge that I can get back up again without it costing me anything other than minimal effort and about 2p in electricity. I love going out on an electric mountain bike and exploring, too, or heading to Bike Park Wales and getting some downhill runs in without needing to book, or queue for, an uplift. Whatever is the right tool for the job.

Calling people out for using an e-bike for day-to-day transport or leisure riding is pretty bizarre, when you consider it. For a start, journeys that the majority of city e-bike riders are doing would otherwise be done by car, or on a bus, where allegations of cheating are pretty rare. People make the decision to ride an e-bike for a whole range of reasons. It might be that parking is an issue and being able to just leave an e-bike outside the office saves them stress and time. It might be that they like to ride to work, but want to do it in normal clothes and don't want to show up a sweaty mess. It might be that their commute is a bit too far to do it under their own steam, day in, day out. We have the longest average commute in Western Europe, after all. If they’re riding for leisure it might be that they’re stretched for time and want to get the most fun out of their few hours they can spare at the trail centre, or on the bridleways. Whatever; you make your choices based on your needs.

Trek Powerfly 9 FS - riding 5.jpg
You can't cheat at having fun!

You can't cheat at going to work. Or the shops. And you can’t cheat at having fun, or getting to the top of the trail centre climb; the irony of someone saying it’s cheating when they’ve just sat in the uplift minibus with their bike on the trailer is a delicious one. Unless someone’s handing you a trophy when you get there, you can’t cheat at just getting around, having fun on your bike. It’s nonsense. If you want to ride hard and get fitter, by all means do. But there's a whole world of reasons for riding a bike out there, and if we want to make cycling normal in the UK then we need to embrace cycling because it's easy, and fun: not just as a sport activity. Electric bikes have a big part to play.


by  Feb 13 2019